(KYIV, UKRAINE) \u2013 Ukraine can outlast Russia in a protracted war of attrition if Western military support remains consistent, according to former British Army soldier and journalist Shaun Pinner.<\/p>\n
Pinner stated that the conflict is now shifting decisively towards an economic struggle rather than a purely military one. \u201cProvided we have the numbers, I think we could last them out,\u201d he said, referencing the recent approval of a substantial 90 billion dollar aid package. This funding, he noted, is designed to sustain Ukraine\u2019s defensive operations for the next couple of years.<\/p>\n
The former soldier, now a journalist documenting the war, assessed that the Kremlin\u2019s position is weakening over time. \u201cThe longer this goes on, it seems to be more detrimental for Putin at the moment, not President Zelenskyy in Ukraine,\u201d Pinner observed.<\/p>\n
Pinner offered a stark assessment of the battlefield reality, explaining that Ukraine\u2019s strategy of active defence is currently the most effective approach. He cautioned against the term \u201cstagnated,\u201d but argued that major offensive operations pose significant risks for Ukrainian forces due to manpower challenges. Instead, he suggested the war is unlikely to be won through tactical advances alone. \u201cThe battlefield is probably not going to be the place where this war is won. It is going to be won politically, economically,\u201d he said. He speculated that an economic collapse in Russia could allow Ukraine to retake occupied territories \u201cwithout a shot being fired.\u201d<\/p>\n
Commenting on the political landscape, Pinner criticised recent statements from the White House, describing a speech by Donald Trump as resembling \u201ca debrief out of the Kremlin.\u201d He stated that the rhetoric from the current US administration, including Vice President JD Vance\u2019s remark that pausing military aid was his \u201cfinest moment,\u201d is actively aiding Moscow.<\/p>\n
\u201cThis is an administration that does not particularly like Ukraine for whatever reason, and it has become more vocal in recent weeks,\u201d Pinner said. He argued that Trump is reinforcing the Russian dictator\u2019s narrative and aggressively targeting NATO, which he described as the Russian leader\u2019s \u201cmajor adversary.\u201d Pinner summarised the US stance bluntly: \u201cHe is not on Ukraine\u2019s side. He is not on Europe\u2019s side.\u201d<\/p>\n
Pinner dismissed the suggestion by a German leader that Ukraine might need to accept temporary territorial concessions in exchange for European Union membership. He highlighted personal stakes in the conflict, noting that his wife lost homes in both Crimea and Mariupol after relocating to escape the initial invasion. Reflecting the sentiment of millions of internally displaced Ukrainians, he rejected the characterisation of occupied land as mere real estate.<\/p>\n
\u201cJD Vance\u2019s comment that we are just haggling over a few square kilometres set everybody raging here. That is our bloody home,\u201d Pinner said. \u201cSix million of us have lost our homes. This is not a regional thing. This is a world thing now involving Israel, Iran, North Korea.\u201d<\/p>\n
Pinner voiced deep concern over the moral implications of negotiating with the Kremlin, questioning why there is little international pressure on a regime \u201caggressively committing war crimes.\u201d He argued that surrendering the strategic defensive belt in eastern Ukraine is an impossibility, as it is vital to preventing a further Russian advance.<\/p>\n
Regarding reports of extreme battlefield desperation, Pinner addressed unverified claims published in the Sunday Times suggesting that isolated Russian units have resorted to cannibalism due to starvation. While he did not witness such incidents personally, he stated that the logistical collapse on the 100 kilometre wide front line makes the scenario plausible. He described vast \u201cgrey zones\u201d where forward Russian troops are cut off from supply lines.<\/p>\n
\u201cIt is incredibly difficult to get logistics in. We ran out of food and ammunition when I was encircled,\u201d Pinner explained, drawing parallels to his own combat experience. He noted that Ukrainian drones are now vital for delivering supplies, but are also used to aggressively interdict Russian resupply efforts. \u201cIt is not surprising that when they cannot get water and are drinking puddle water and desperately need food, it is not in the realms of impossibility,\u201d he said.<\/p>\n
On the economic front, Pinner described the systematic theft of Ukrainian grain by Russia from occupied territories as a direct funding mechanism for the war. He confirmed that the practice is ongoing and highly organised, extending beyond agricultural theft to the outright seizure of homes and vehicles.<\/p>\n
\u201cIf you are taking stolen grain, you are funding the Russian war effort. That is as simple as it gets,\u201d he stated, condemning the moral compass of nations trading in these illicit goods. He described a sense of bewilderment among Ukrainians regarding countries that continue to purchase Russian oil or grain while atrocities are being documented.<\/p>\n